SC Orders SIT Probe against BJP's Vijay Shah for Remarks on Col Sofiya Qureshi, Stays His Arrest
Debayan Roy (Bar  and  Bench) 19 May 2025
The Supreme Court on Friday censured Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) minister Kunwar Vijay Shah for his remarks against Colonel Sofiya Qureshi, who briefed the media during India's recent cross-border military response, Operation Sindoor, against Pakistan.
 
The Bench of Justice Surya Kant and Justice N Kotiswar Singh ordered constitution of a Special Investigation Team (SIT) of three IPS officers of Madhya Pradesh cadre to probe the matter. It asked the Director General of Police to constitute the SIT by tomorrow.
 
"We are constituting a SIT with three IPS officers and one should be the rank of IG or DGP rank. All of them should be [from] outside the State. It is a litmus test and we want the state to submit the SIT report to us. We would like to have a very close watch," the Court said.
 
Meanwhile, the Court stayed Shah's arrest and ordered him to join the investigation. 
 
During the hearing, the Court questioned the apology made by Shah and said he had not committed any contempt of court to express apology for his words.
 
"The kind of crass comments you made, completely thoughtlessly... We don't need this apology," the Court remarked, adding that it was an attempt to wriggle out of consequences.
 
The Court further remarked that Shah was exposed in public and he should have been wise enough to own up to his actions.
 
"You are saying 'if' I have done," Justice remarked. 
 
The Court also questioned the State inaction in the matter. "What have you done after registering the FIR? Has he[SHO] examined what kind of offence is made out. What is the status," it said.
 
The Court added that the State should have done "something more" by now. 
 
Shah had stirred controversy after he reportedly remarked: “Those who widowed our daughters, we sent a sister of their own to teach them a lesson. The comment was widely viewed as a veiled reference to Colonel Qureshi.
 
Madhya Pradesh High Court on May 14 initiated a suo motu case against him and directed registration of a criminal case against him. He then moved the Court.
 
"His comments are disparaging and dangerous, not just to the officer in question but to the armed forces itself," the High Court had said last week, while taking suo motu congnizance of his remarks.
 
The High Court had said Shah used the “language of the gutters” by allegedly calling Colonel Qureshi the “sister of terrorists.”
 
Following the High Court order, an FIR was registered against Shah late on May 14 under Sections 152, 196(1)(b), and 197(1)(c) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). 
 
On May 15, the High Court pulled up the State for drafting the FIR in a manner that it could tomorrow be quashed for not explicitly mentioning the actions of the accused. 
 
The Court went on direct that its May 14 order shall be read as part of the FIR for all judicial, quasi-judicial and investigative purposes.
 
Today, the top court issued notice on Shah's petition and ordered that an SIT will probe the matter. 
 
"Having gone through the statements by the petitioner and the FIR, we are of the opinion that the subject FIR shall be probed by a SIT with three senior IPS officers... Let the SIT be constituted by tomorrow. Let one member be a woman officer. Both members shall be above the rank of superintendent of police. The head member shall not be below the rank of IG or DGP. Let the petitioner co-operate. As of now his arrest shall remain stayed. Though we are not inclined to monitor the probe, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, we direct the SIT to submit the outcome of its probe through a status report before this court. The first report shall be filed and the case be taken up in the first week of vacations," the Court ordered.
 
Comments
angelo.extross
4 weeks ago
Why the pin-drop silence of the Hon. Prime Minister, the Hon. Home Minister, and the Hon. Defence Minister? This is not good for the country and does not send a good message to the world before our Good-will missions go out into the world.
Meenal Mamdani
Replied to angelo.extross comment 4 weeks ago
The goodwill missions cannot hide the fact that this govt, Prime Minister on downwards, has targeted Muslims, allowing extra-judicial acts from Hindutva supporters.

India has lost its prestige for being a secular country where people of all religions can live in harmony.

The current GoI wants to turn India into a mirror image of Pakistan which is not secular, is a theocracy, where the minorities are often persecuted and where the press is muzzled.
iaminprabhu
4 weeks ago
This Kuwar Vijay Shah must be immediately SACKED by BJP without any delay as its already DAMAGING the image of the great work done by it in Operation SINDOOR!

No amount of apology can be accepted for the CRASS & LOW comments made by him against an LADY ARMY OFFICER
Meenal Mamdani
4 weeks ago
The judges are suddenly developing a spine!!
Is it too late?
Closing the stable door after the horse has bolted?
deepak.narain
4 weeks ago
“Those who widowed our daughters, we sent a sister of their own to teach them a lesson." Making mountain of a molehill. Finding virtue where abundant evidence is available to the contrary. Exceptions do not make the rule. False secularism!
Judges, Money and Markets: Consequences of the Apparent Trust Deficit
Sucheta Dalal, 16 May 2025
At a time when most of us were riveted on Operation Sindoor, a decision by judges of the Supreme Court of India (SC) to voluntarily declare their assets went largely unnoticed. The disclosures are a step forward from the sporadic and...
Durga Mehta: Recognising a Nursing Legend on International Nursing Day
Dr Swati Rane 16 May 2025
As we celebrate International Nurses Week and Nurses' Day on 12th May, it is both timely and essential to reflect on the profound contributions of nursing leaders who have shaped the profession in India. One such towering figure is...
Lessons from the Past 128: Beware of the One-person Company
Walter Vieira, 16 May 2025
When we talk about family business, we think about a family, and maybe even about two or three generations. But there are times when we encounter a one-man institution. A person who has the intellect and the capability to build a...
Supreme Court Flags Misuse of Section 498A IPC, Acquits Husband In 26-year Cruelty and Dowry Case
Ritwik Choudhury (Bar  and  Bench) 16 May 2025
The Supreme Court recently acquitted a man in a 26-year-old dowry and cruelty case, while raising concerns about the misuse of Section 498A (cruelty to married woman) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961,...
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback