Delhi HC Orders Dabur To Prove Claims Against Fluoride-based Toothpaste after Colgate Objects to Ad
SN Thyagarajan (Bar  and  Bench) 11 April 2025
The Delhi High Court recently directed Dabur India Ltd. to submit scientific evidence supporting claims in its advertisement that fluoride in toothpaste can cause adverse health effects, such as lower IQ in children, brittle bones, and spotting on teeth.
 
Justice Amit Bansal passed the order on an application by Colgate-Palmolive to restrain such claims in Dabur’s advertisement campaign. 
 
Colgate alleged that the advertisements were misleading and disparaged fluoride-based toothpaste, thereby indirectly targeting Colgate toothpaste. 
 
The Court has sought Dabur's response in the matter. 
 
“Along with the reply, the defendant (Dabur) shall place on record material to justify the following claims made by the defendant in the said advertisement on account of the presence of fluoride in a toothpaste: - (i) Lower IQ in kids (ii) Brittle Bones (iii) Spotting on teeth," the Court added.
 
Colgate has contended that the tagline “Does your favourite toothpaste have fluoride?”, which was featured in Dabur’s print ad on World Oral Health Day, was a veiled reference to Colgate’s product, which contains fluoride and is a market leader. 
 
The ad appeared in The Times of India on the same day as Colgate’s own front-page promotion of fluoride toothpaste.
 
Dabur's advertisements have claimed that fluoride toothpastes can cause health issues like lower IQ in children, brittle bones, and dental fluorosis. Colgate argues that these claims are scientifically unfounded and misleading, given that fluoride in regulated amounts (up to 1000 ppm) is approved by health authorities worldwide for preventing tooth decay. The company contended that Dabur's campaign constituted unfair competition as it disparages an entire category of products rather than just making comparative claims about its own offerings.
 
This legal battle has its roots in a 2019 case. Earlier, the Court ordered Dabur to modify advertisements that were found to mimic Colgate's packaging too closely. While Dabur complied with the visual changes, Colgate has now taken issue with
Dabur's continued claims about fluoride-based toothpastes. 
 
Dabur has submitted that it would, without prejudice to its legal rights, remove the word “favourite” from the ad. 
 
However, the company also defended its campaign, arguing that the ads merely highlighted “potential risks” faced by consumers based on selected studies. 
 
Justice Bansal has granted Dabur two weeks to file a reply and Colgate two weeks thereafter to submit a rejoinder. The matter is listed for further hearing on May 27, 2025.
 
Comments
Maha Misfire at Mahakumbh: Piyush Goyal’s Rant Exposes the Frustration among Entrepreneurs
Sucheta Dalal, 11 April 2025
At the grandly titled Start-up Mahakumbh last week, Union minister for commerce and industry Piyush Goyal delivered yet another controversial speech—one that swiftly turned into a lightning rod for criticism. This was not his first...
Dr Reddy’s Dilemma: Repeat Story of Promoter’s Interest Outweighing Listed Entity
Ranganathan V, 11 April 2025
On 5 April 2025, Dr Reddy’s Laboratories Ltd (DRL) informed the stock exchanges of the receipt of a show-cause notice from the tax authorities to raise a demand of Rs2,396 crore, which triggered this article.
 
The company has...
Byju Raveendran Sued in US over Alleged Orchestration of US$533mn Fund Diversion
Moneylife Digital Team 10 April 2025
BYJU's Alpha Inc, a Delaware-based special purpose vehicle created to manage US$1.5bn (billion) in term loan B proceeds, has filed a lawsuit in the US against Byju Raveendran, co-founder and former chief executive officer (CEO) of...
Rupee Volatility To Spell Earnings Turbulence for Certain Sectors: CRISIL
Moneylife Digital Team 08 April 2025
A sharp swing in the rupee's value could destabilise earnings in key Indian export-driven sectors such as pharmaceuticals, information technology (IT) services and gems and jewellery, according to a research note issued by CRISIL...
Free Helpline
Legal Credit
Feedback